Skip to content
Prices verified · May 22, 2026MethodologyAbout
eSIMRated
ReviewsDestinationsComparisonsGuides
Compare Plans
Home›Methodology
eSIMRated Editorial Team

How we test and rate eSIM providers

eSIMRated tests 20 eSIM providers on four devices (iPhone 15 Pro, iPhone 16 Pro, Samsung Galaxy S24, and Samsung Galaxy S25) across 100+ destinations. We rate each provider across 5 categories on a 0.0 to 5.0 scale. Prices are re-checked regularly and may vary by region. Prices last verified May 22, 2026.

eSIMRated tests every eSIM provider hands-on before publishing a review. We buy real plans at retail, activate them on four test devices, and check coverage, app quality, and price against the provider's own storefront. We publish no speed figure for any provider, because we run no throughput tests. Our ratings are independent editorial judgments, not influenced by advertising or affiliate relationships.

Independence statement: No provider can pay for a higher rating. Our scoring methodology applies identically to every provider reviewed on this site.

Test hardware

Testing devices

We test on physical devices, not emulators. All four devices run the latest available OS at the time of each quarterly review cycle. Testing on both iOS and Android catches activation differences, app quality gaps, and carrier compatibility issues that appear only on one platform.

  • iPhone 15 Pro (iOS 17+)
  • iPhone 16 Pro (iOS 18+)
  • Samsung Galaxy S24 (Android 14)
  • Samsung Galaxy S25 (Android 15)
Network data

Speed and network data

We publish no network speed figure for any provider. We do not run our own throughput measurements across 215 destinations, and a provider's own marketing number is not a test result. The Speed category score reflects published carrier partnerships and network generation, not a measured throughput.

Coverage and carrier data come from each provider's published network list, cross-referenced with GSMA network maps and OpenSignal. Pricing comes from the provider's own storefront, re-checked on the date shown on each page.

20 destinations where we buy and activate plans directly

  • Japan
  • South Korea
  • Thailand
  • Singapore
  • Indonesia
  • France
  • Germany
  • Italy
  • Spain
  • United Kingdom
  • United States
  • Canada
  • Mexico
  • Brazil
  • Australia
  • UAE
  • India
  • Turkey
  • Egypt
  • South Africa
Data accuracy

Pricing verification

We re-check pricing against each provider's official website. All prices are in USD unless stated otherwise. We record the date of each verification and display it on review pages.

When discrepancies exist between what a provider shows in-app versus on their website, we use the lower published price. Prices are re-checked regularly and may vary by region. Every page carries the date its pricing was last verified, so you can judge how current it is before you buy.

Current verification date: Prices last verified May 22, 2026.

Coverage claims

Coverage verification

We cross-reference provider coverage claims with GSMA network maps and OpenSignal data. We verify that listed carriers are active and accessible in each destination.

We do not claim in-country testing for all 185 destinations. Where we have verified data from direct testing, we note it clearly. Where we rely on provider-reported data, we state that on the page.

Rating system

Five categories, 0.0 to 5.0 scale

We rate providers across five categories: Coverage, Speed, App Quality, Pricing, and Support. Each category scores 0.0 to 5.0 in increments of 0.1. The overall rating is a weighted average. The weights reflect what matters most to travelers making a purchase decision.

CategoryWeightWhat we assess
Coverage25%Country count, network partners per destination, and confirmation that the listed carriers are active
Speed20%Carrier partnerships the provider publishes and whether 5G is listed. Not a throughput measurement, because we run none
App Quality15%Interface usability, data monitoring, top-up flow, and the setup steps required on iOS and Android
Pricing25%Per-GB value, plan flexibility, top-up availability, value against the market for the same destination
Support15%Which support channels a provider offers, the languages it covers, and how clearly its help pages answer common problems
Independence

Editorial independence

eSIMRated is an independent comparison platform. Ratings reflect independent testing and editorial judgment. Every provider is evaluated using the same methodology and receives no preferential treatment in ratings or rankings.

We earn revenue through affiliate commissions when you purchase an eSIM through links on our site. No provider can pay for a higher rating, an Editor's Choice badge, or early access to reviews. Every provider review includes genuine negatives. If a provider has a flaw, we report it.

Our commitments

  • Every provider is purchased and tested at our own expense
  • Ratings are determined by test data, not affiliate revenue
  • Genuine pros and cons reported for every provider
  • Pricing re-checked against official provider sources, with the verification date published
  • No provider previews or approves reviews before publication
  • All providers evaluated using identical criteria regardless of affiliate relationships
Freshness

Update cadence

Pricing: re-checked against official provider pages, with the date of the last check shown on every page. Coverage data: updated when a provider changes its network partners. Full reviews: refreshed on a quarterly cycle. Speed figures: none published, for any provider, in any destination.

Pricing dataRe-checked regularly; last verified May 22, 2026
Provider ratingsRe-evaluated each review cycle
Coverage dataUpdated on provider network change
Speed figuresNone published; we run no throughput tests
Editorial contentReviewed for accuracy each cycle
App quality scoresUpdated with each review cycle
Limitations

What we do not do

  • We do not personally travel to every country we cover
  • We do not run throughput tests, and we publish no speed figure for any provider
  • We do not time activation, and we publish no activation success rate
  • We do not accept payment for higher ratings
  • We do not guarantee that prices shown reflect real-time availability
  • We do not allow providers to preview or approve reviews before publication
Meet the teamEditorial policy

Questions about our methodology? Contact editorial@esimrated.com

Last updated: May 22, 2026

eSIMRated

Independent eSIM reviews and head-to-head comparisons.

Reviews

  • Airalo
  • HelloRoam
  • Holafly
  • Saily
  • Nomad
  • Flexiroam
  • Ubigi
  • GigSky
  • Alosim
  • Instabridge
  • All reviews

Destinations

  • Japan
  • South Korea
  • Thailand
  • France
  • United Kingdom
  • Italy
  • Spain
  • United States
  • Australia
  • Germany
  • All destinations

Compare

  • Airalo vs. Flexiroam
  • Airalo vs. GigSky
  • GigSky vs. Ubigi
  • Airalo vs. Nomad
  • Saily vs. Nomad
  • Airalo vs. Saily
  • Holafly vs. Saily
  • Airalo vs. Ubigi
  • All matchups

Best For

  • Best for Travel
  • Best for Business
  • Best for Students
  • Best for Families
  • Best for Digital Nomads
  • Cheapest Plans
  • Unlimited Data
  • Free eSIM
  • Best for Cruises
  • Best Prepaid
  • Best Worldwide

Compatible Phones

  • iPhone
  • Samsung
  • Google Pixel
  • Smartwatches
  • Laptops
  • All devices

Guides

  • What is an eSIM?
  • Activate eSIM
  • Transfer eSIM
  • Apple Watch eSIM
  • eSIM for Laptops
  • All guides

Use Cases

  • All reviews
  • Best App
  • Travel
  • Cheapest
  • Digital Nomads

The Publication

  • Methodology
  • Editorial policy
  • Corrections
  • About
  • Contact
  • Terms
  • Privacy
Affiliate disclosure. eSIMRated is an independent review publication. Some outbound links to providers are affiliate links, which means we may earn a small commission if you purchase through them, at no additional cost to you. Editorial selections are made before commercial considerations and are never influenced by them. Prices shown are re-checked regularly and may vary by region. © 2026 eSIMRated.